clock menu more-arrow no yes

Filed under:

Watch: Can a $200 Cast-Iron Pan Sear Steaks Better Than a $30 Lodge Pan?

Testing the Butter Pan against the easily recognizable Lodge

If you buy something from an Eater link, Vox Media may earn a commission. See our ethics policy.

There’s really no going back once a cast-iron pan lands in your kitchen, often rendering all your other kitchen pots and pans obsolete. A sturdy cast iron — which How to Make It host Katie Pickens recently saw the process behind creating — will make the crispiest fried rice, give your steaks a more perfect sear, bake knockout cornbread, and perfectly crisp the skin on your roast chicken.

Lodge is an easily recognized manufacturer of these most durable pans, but Butter Pan is a new maker on the market selling a polished, uniquely smooth version said to be “thinner and lighter than other cast iron.” It retails for $195, and the average Lodge pan for about $30. Kitchen Gadget Test Show host Esther Choi is testing the two pans against each other in this episode with three different tests.

See more Eater-tested kitchen gadgets and appliances | Follow Eater on YouTube for more videos


How a Family of Saffron Farmers Harvests the World’s Most Expensive Spice


Grocery Store Shortages Are Back. Here’s Why.


A Peanut-Braised Chicken With Coconut Carolina Rice Recipe to Warm the Soul

Sign up for the Sign up for the Eater newsletter

The freshest news from the food world every day