clock menu more-arrow no yes mobile

Filed under:

Watch: Can a $200 Cast-Iron Pan Sear Steaks Better Than a $30 Lodge Pan?

Testing the Butter Pan against the easily recognizable Lodge

If you buy something from an Eater link, Vox Media may earn a commission. See our ethics policy.

There’s really no going back once a cast-iron pan lands in your kitchen, often rendering all your other kitchen pots and pans obsolete. A sturdy cast iron — which How to Make It host Katie Pickens recently saw the process behind creating — will make the crispiest fried rice, give your steaks a more perfect sear, bake knockout cornbread, and perfectly crisp the skin on your roast chicken.

Lodge is an easily recognized manufacturer of these most durable pans, but Butter Pan is a new maker on the market selling a polished, uniquely smooth version said to be “thinner and lighter than other cast iron.” It retails for $195, and the average Lodge pan for about $30. Kitchen Gadget Test Show host Esther Choi is testing the two pans against each other in this episode with three different tests.

See more Eater-tested kitchen gadgets and appliances | Follow Eater on YouTube for more videos

Holiday Gift Guides

Do All Your Last-Minute Holiday Shopping on Goldbelly

Gastropod

New Jersey’s Forgotten Caviar Boom

Eater Travel

An Eater’s Guide to Whistler, British Columbia

Sign up for the Sign up for the Eater newsletter

The freshest news from the food world every day