Onespot for NYC's Chin Chin; Half a Star for LA's Caffe Roma

NYC: The Dining Room At Chin Chin [photo via:Chin Chin]

New York Times/Sam Sifton: Chin Chin, 1 star
New York Times/Ligaya Mishan: Pilar Cuban Eatery
Village Voice/Robert Sistema: The Matball Shop
Village Voice/Sarah DiGregorio: Merit Kabob and Dumpling Palace
New York Magazine/Robin Raisfeld & Rob Patronite: Saltie and Cheeky
GQ/Alan Richman: La Mangeoire
Time Out New York/Gabriella Gershenson: Mile End, 4 stars (out of 5)
Insatiable Critic/Gael Greene: Pies 'n' Thighs
The New Yorker/Lauren Collins: A Voce Columbus
Blomberg/Ryan Sutton: Colicchio & Sons

Los Angeles Times/S. Irene Virbila: Caffe Roma Half a star
LA Weekly/Jonathan Gold: Sunnin

San Francisco Chronicle/Michael Bauer: Vik's Chaat Corner, 2.5 stars
San Francisco Chronicle/Carey Sweet: P/30, 2 stars
SF Examiner/Patricia Unterman: Koi Place
SF Weekly/Jonathan Kauffman: Heart
SF Bay Guardian/Paul Reidinger: Nihon Whisky Lounge

Miami New Times/Lee Klein: The Morgans Restaurant

Chicago Sun-Times/Pat Bruno: Branch 27

Washington Post/Tom Sietsema: Cosmopolitan Grill 1.5 stars
Washington Post/Tom Sietsema: Bond 45,(First Bite)

Boston Herald/Mat Schaffer: Bombay Club

Didn't see your favorite big-city reviewer? Let us know!