New York Times/Sam Sifton: The Breslin, 1 star
New York Times/Julia Moskin: Bar Pleiades and Ardesia
Bloomberg/Ryan Sutton: The Breslin
New York Magazine/Adam Platt: Maialino, 3 stars
GQ/Alan Richman: Gino
Village Voice/Robert Sietsema: The Breslin
Village Voice/Sarah DiGregorio: Highlands
NY Post/Steve Cuozzo: Robert
The New Yorker/Lauren Collins: Tipsy Parson
Time Out New York/Jay Cheshes: Purple Yam, 4 stars (out of 5)
Crain's/Gael Greene: Cascabel
Chicago Tribune/Phil Vettel: Gemini Bistro
Chicago Tribune/Phil Vettel: Big Jones
LA Times/S. Irene Virbila: Osteria La Buca, 1.5 stars
LA Weekly/Jonathan Gold: Fig
San Francisco Chronicle/Michael Bauer: Rosso , 3 stars
San Francisco Chronicle/Michael Bauer: La Costanera, 2 stars
San Francisco Examiner/Patricia Unterman: Grain
Contra Costa Times/Chrissa Ventrelle: Five, 3.5 stars
Miami Herald/Victoria Pesce Elliott: Botequim Carioca, 2.5 stars
Miami New Times/Lee Klein: Prelude by Barton G.
Boston Herald/Mat Schaffer: Post 930
Portland Mercury/Patrick Alan Coleman: Fats
Didn't see your favorite big-city reviewer? Let us know!